Once I catch it, all will be well
It is a source of amusement when dogs chase their tails. They run round in circles, but hardly ever manage to catch them.
Sadly, this analogy seems to apply to much that is going on in wildlife conservation today. Some examples:
In December last year, the IUCN organized an urgent meeting in Botswana to address the elephant poaching crisis. Present were some high-level officials from African elephant range states including Gabon, Kenya, Niger and Zambia; ivory transit states like Vietnam, Philippines and Malaysia; and ivory destination states including China and Thailand. The meeting was immediately hailed a success although only six of the countries represented signed the agreement drafted by the Summit.
Of the fourteen measures proposed at the meeting the most urgent was the need to classify wildlife trafficking as a ‘serious crime’ – a move that will supposedly unlock international law enforcement co-operation provided for under the United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime. This co-operation includes mutual legal assistance, asset seizure and forfeiture, extradition and other tools to hold criminals accountable for wildlife crime.
Other measures agreed to include engaging communities, strengthening national laws to secure maximum wildlife crime sentences, and mobilizing financial and technical resources to combat wildlife crime and reducing demand for illegal ivory.
Hot on the tail of that conference came the London Summit on Illegal Wildlife Trade in February this year. The aim of that conference was to agree a high level of political commitment to take urgent action.
The London conference, which focused on elephants, rhinos and tigers, aimed to tackle three interlinked aspects of illegal wildlife trade:
1. strengthening law enforcement and the criminal justice system
2. reducing demand for illegal wildlife products
3. supporting the development of sustainable livelihoods for communities affected by illegal wildlife trade.
A recommendation of the London Summit was to organize a follow-up meeting in Botswana next year to gauge progress.
This month a workshop was organized for Mozambique. The conference looked at the causes of wildlife crime such as weak enforcement, vulnerable borders, corruption, a lack of institutional co-ordination, the existing legal frameworks, human/elephant conflict, human activity within conservation areas and a lack of appreciation for wildlife by the general populace.
Another conference this month organized by the very good Rosa Luxemburg Foundation stated that:
“What is clear from the discussions generated in the workshop is that organized crime in Southern Africa is evolving from a crime issue into a governance issue, and that this may require a different toolbox from the one currently being employed. With the tight triumvirate of political elite, business elite and criminal actors (including foreign actors) becoming a dominant feature of organized crime, there is a clear challenge in mobilizing political will to establish the state institutions and regulatory frameworks that would need be required to respond effectively.”
Richard Leakey in Kenya recently revealed that the poaching kingpins are well known to the Kenyan authorities but that they enjoy a great level of political protection and could well remain immune from prosecution.
There can be no doubt that international conferences on the issue of illegal wildlife trade are welcome. But it would seem that delegates are talking past each other. The Rosa Luxemburg Foundation delegates clearly indicated that organized crime has become so well established in governments that no progress is likely to be made by calls for better law enforcement and improving the criminal justice system. If there is no political will to halt poaching and trafficking we can organize conferences well into the next century.
But those will be about how to protect zoo animals from being poached – all those in the wild will be long gone.
Picture credit: http://bit.ly/1ir74SL
If you have not already signed up to our mailing list, you can add your name here and keep up to date with our ongoing work and, most importantly, DONATE to support our work to conserve the remaining fragile lion populations. Thank you.
