Why was I born?
Further to our announcement on the 4th April about the scandalous inbreeding of white lions at Paradise Wildlife Park in Hertfordshire, an article was published in today’s Sunday Times (7th April 2013) entitled “Inbred” white lion cub puts cat among pigeons” (subscription required to read the full article).
In this article Paradise took the opportunity to respond:
Firstly, we hear that Paradise have thought better of the £999 per person/couple (they quoted both!) they were charging to pet this cub and have now reduced the price to £250 per person. Perhaps unluckily for them, we have the screen print of their original price in case they should wish to deny any such extravagant pricing policy!
Secondly, they now tell us that these petting sessions will be taking place during the veterinary inspections! We’re sure the vet will be thrilled with this and since we are also told that the cub is proving to be “a huge draw for visitors”, the vet may have to do some prolonged inspections.
Thirdly, the owners of the Wildlife Park maintain that this cub is a “natural variant” and the cub and both its parents are all healthy. There is little that is “natural” about breeding close relatives that carry the recessive leucistic gene in order to ensure the white coat in any offspring. Incidentally, it is unusual for only one cub to be born in a litter. Did this cub have any brothers and sisters that died before they could be also be presented to an unsuspecting public? Reduced fertility is associated with inbreeding, and an Italian zoo breeding white lions reported that 17 of 19 cubs were either stillborn or died within a month.
Fourthly, Paradise Wildlife Park apparently prides itself on its conservation work. They quote the sponsoring of “vaccination programmes to protect wild African lions” to illustrate their point. This project was called “Life Lion” and was a programme set up to vaccinate domestic dogs against canine distemper in villages around the Serengeti National Park to hopefully protect lions and other carnivore species. It was started in 1995, meant to last 10 years, but trailed off in 1999 as funding ran out. In addition, over 75% of funds raised by Friends of Paradise Park in 2010 and 2011 went into refurbishment and building of new enclosures at Paradise and Wildlife Heritage Foundation.
Fifthly, the article correctly points out that BIAZA (the British and Irish Association of Zoos and Aquariums) has said there is no conservation value in breeding white lions, are produced by severe inbreeding and can cause a number of congenital disorders and abnormalities. Note that the US Association of Zoos and Aquariums similarly cautioned their members.
Sixthly, Paradise Wildlife Park admit that they do not have full records for the cub’s parents but “had traced their ancestry back five generations”. This is a stretch. The cub’s mother was imported from South African breeders who keep no studbooks. The cub’s father was born at West Midland Safari Park to parents also imported from South Africa. The South African breeders provide white lions to zoos and to trophy hunters. Regardless, all white lions are derived from a single pride in the Timbavati region near Kruger National Park where some members expressed the then rare leucistic coat colour. Now it is estimated there are 300-400 white lions in captivity in zoos and breeding farms, all closely related to each other.
The article ends with a statement from the Park that “the money paid by visitors to see the cub will fund our conservation work”. Meanwhile, BIAZA states that “Inbreeding practices as necessary to produce white lions impair the ability to develop and maintain sustainable captive populations and to deliver the appropriate animal welfare and conservation educational messages”.
We call on BIAZA to remind Paradise Wildlife Park of this statement, the more so because Paradise is embarking on another white lion breeding programme at their sister facility, the Wildlife Heritage Foundation in Kent. There, two females imported from South Africa will join a half-brother of the new cub, born in 2009. The public might not be aware of how white lion cubs are produced, but the zoo governing body in the UK cannot claim such innocence.
Picture credit: http://thetim.es/10tF6JB
If you have not already signed up to our mailing list, you can add your name here and keep up to date with our ongoing work and, most importantly, DONATE to support our work to conserve the remaining fragile lion populations. Thank you.